Here we go:
Tier # 1 Tentative List (pretty much taken from the thread: Smoke that caught you by surprise in a good way)
Room 101 the Big Payback
Arturo Fuente Sun Grown Chateau
Diesel Unlimited Gordo
Mark Twain Presidente
Tatuaje Ambos Mundos Robusto #1 Habano
Espinosa Proxy No. 24 Toro
ESTD 1844 Anejado No. 58 Solomon
Xikar HC Maduro Churchill
Bahia Blu Churchill
Asylum Schizo Double Toro

10 Cigars, I'm thinking the price would be $34.99