I didn't care for the AVO cigarillos. Kind of bitter, nasty and musty if I remember correctly. The Davidoff demi-tasse and panatelas are nice but expensive. Skip the Clubs. La Auroras are just too tiny. Montercristos are okay, same with Partagas. Strangely, I think Macanudos are good in small size because the mildness seems to keep them from being harsh.

You might also want to check out Camacho Machitos if you can find them. And are Petite Cabaiguans too big? They're a great smoke.