There's only one of these cigar of the month clubs that I'd actually consider and it's from http://www.cigarhustler.com/

I am NOT a member but I've seen member's posts of stuff like this:


same member(of another forum) posted:
Last Month's sampler:
◦ Tabak Negra Toro
◦ Viaje Platino Sueno
◦ Alec Bradley Black Market Churchill
◦ My Father Le Bijou Petite Robusto
◦ El Centurion Robusto

next month was:


month after that:


His posts pretty much sealed the deal that this is a legitimately good club. I've never seen a CotM club sampler that I wouldn't toss away half the cigars, until this.