Despite overwhelming evidence to the contrary, I qualified for the win based on reviews. Or maybe it was a random drawing, in my case. JustTroItIn and I won a Barling pipe courtesy of NeverBend. The pipe arrived today and man, is it sweet. It's a 5579 with a long shank. This form is new to me and I find it to be very elegant in person. This whole review/bombing run was entertaining and edifying from start to finish. Capping it off with a pipe prize is just classy as hell. Thanks Pete and Tobias and all the participants!