Thanks for the detailed write-up, Pete! It's interesting to see these all stacked up against one another, and not just by brand but vitola as well.

I've had the PdR, Cinco Vegas, and RP and I think you've got them ranked about the same as I would. I have had a few of the Rocky Patels that were decent, but you nailed it on their inconsistency.

Also, it's funny you mention the Cinco Vegas Double Nickel specifically, because that's the only vitola in the line that I've really enjoyed - the others seemed bland to me.