I live on both ends of the spectrum. Both work well. One just leaves you with more money for cigars. Not sure that one works any better than the other.

In the office. Would buy this one again in a second, but very difficult to find humidors made from 1/2" Walnut stock with 3/8" spanish cedar liners at a reasonable price these days. This warhorse still looks good and works well after 20 years of service.




One of 9 that lives in a 154 quart cooler in the basement. I have a couple of these with cedar trays for cigars that aren't in cello.