Here's a few suggestions that are of different shapes and sizes and showing the price I've been seeing them at:

Mild-Med Casa de Garcia Corona Connecticut $1.10
Mild-Med Gurkha Elegance Churchill $2.50
Mild-Med Perdomo Tierra del Sol Torpedo $1.80
Mild-Med Thompson Honduran Finas Churchill $1.90
Mild-Med Toraño Dominican Selection Toro $2.00
Mild-Med Toraño Vega Dominican Torpedo $2.00

All-in-all, I'd look at a Thompson's catalog and go with a house brand that fits the bill. I'd then take off the Thompson bands and create my own to replace - and make it a bit special in the process. Kinda' like your own business card...