28th Birthday Cigar

[Cardinal]

The padron and melanio's are favorites of mine as well. But I haven't yet had an Opus or a Liga Unico so I'm leaning a bit that direction so far.

- - - Updated - - -



Why do I get the feeling they aren't actually made of rubber but are made of animal intestine instead?

Funny, I was just talking with Brimy about this kinda thing yesterday. We were both leaning towards a known commodity for a celebratory cigar. I'd hate to smoke a new one that just didn't do it for me on a special occasion.

One of my top choices personally would be the Melanio Maduro, and the natural isn't too far behind.

[JollyRogers]

Funny, I was just talking with Brimy about this kinda thing yesterday. We were both leaning towards a known commodity for a celebratory cigar. I'd hate to smoke a new one that just didn't do it for me on a special occasion.

One of my top choices personally would be the Melanio Maduro, and the natural isn't too far behind.

You do make a good point...damn way to make an easy decision difficult. I do have a Padron 1964 Natural TAA edition that's interesting...

[TreySC]

You do make a good point...damn way to make an easy decision difficult. I do have a Padron 1964 Natural TAA edition that's interesting...

It's your Birthday, why not both? Out of your list the only one I've had is the Dirty rat and to be honest I wasn't blown away by it.