You could probably tell us better than us tell you!

The only thing I can recommend is make sure you really like the cigars before committing to a box. I usually smoke at least a 5er before going for a box.
I tend to rotate various Olivas, Short Story madies, and have been considering Nica Rusticas and JdN.

I saw some KFC boxes going pretty cheap too if you like those.
My box budget is usually $150 or less.
Among those I need to try that have caught my attention value wise are Southern Draw Cigars, Sam Leccia Luchadors, and now Asylum (thanks!)