What was your first cigar?

[AlanS]

CAO America Robusto.
Found it in the parking lot outside of a local B&M in the middle of the night. Thought, "What the heck. Might as well!" and smoked that sucker when I got home.

The first cigar that got me hooked (and got me sick) was Arturo Fuente Don Carlos #2.

Ditto on the Don Carlos, first one turned me all kinds of green!