cigar aficionado top 25 2015

[Demuths1770]

i think both the La Mission and the king is dead are both well deserving of being inside the top 25. i really think cote d'or also deserved a spot in the top 10. for me that was the best cigar i smoke in 2015

[FireRunner]

I wasn't happy to see the My Father 1922 ranked #1 this year. Same as I wasn't happy to see the Oliva Melanio ranked #1 last year. Why? because both have been regular smokes of mine for several years. This year the Melanio has been a bare to get, almost all stores have it on back order and when they do arrive they are still a little "green". Luckily, I had about 30 Melanio sticks from before the ranking.

Now, this year the My Father 1922 is #1! So, it'll be tough to get another one of my regulars! While I'm happy to see these two get attention, I'm not happy about how it will impact my inventory In other news I don't really care for the list this year. The only other cigars I enjoy on this list is the L'Atelier La Mission and the Montecristo Espada. The Ashton Symmetry is an excellent cigar but not at that price point. If the Symmetry was under $10 I'd put it in the top 5 (The Oliva Melanio is under $10 for the same size stick).

[tonyzoc]

I was surprised by CAO Flathead at #3 also. While I like this cigar, and wouldn't have blinked if we're at #22, no way it's #3. I'm not even sure the 660 is the 3rd best flathead. I'll take the 554 or Sparkplug over the 660 every time.

Sent from my HTC One using Tapatalk