What cigar do I owe Horseshoe?

[williegstyles]

After CIA type investigative work by @jp1979 my cigar house of cards was brought down and I lost a bet to @Horseshoe . See that poll/thread earlier today for more details. Bottom line is I now owe @Horseshoe a cigar and he would like another famous DogRockets poll to decide. These cigars were his choices and he has agreed to stand true with the winning selection. Decide his fate!

I'm thinking that @jp1979 had a confidential informant. Not too sure his investigative skills are all THAT!!!!

[DogRockets]

I'm thinking that @jp1979 had a confidential informant. Not too sure his investigative skills are all THAT!!!!

Whoa whoa whoa! This is getting more sinister by the hour. A conspiracy is afoot! Next time on "As cigarbum turns....."