In the $5-8 range I've become a huge fan of Oliva Vs as a midrange cigar and I've stocked up a few boxes of them. Several from Pepin too, including Le Bijou, FldA, and My Father. I've got bunches of all of those.

For cheapies, I know I've been pimping Chillin' Moose big time lately. The coronas are under $2 and I've been smoking bunches of them. I'll definitely buy another box when I get close to finishing my current one. I'd easily pay double the asking price for these. I've given a few to friends and they have all enjoyed them.