Picky in the way the OP used it. I'll try anything and smoke it to the nub to see if it gets better, but so far, there are only 10-12 cigars that I buy by the box and keep on hand.

Variety and trying new cigars is part of my interest in the hobby, and from time to time I'll buy two of something new, that I've read about, or that just catches my eye, that's how I find new cigars to add to my 10-12.

Lately I've been on a quest to find the best inexpensive cigars---have tried alot of dog rockets---and found one or two gems. Most of what I smoke is in the $6 to $7 range, but there are a couple of $17 cigars that I love, and I want some $3 cigars in my rotation to keep my average cost below $8.