I'll second the Oliva Vs and Anejo 46s. Lots of good recommendations in the thread really. The My Father #1 is an excellent choice as well - you can't go wrong with any from that line, honestly.

I'll throw out the Espinose Laranja and Illusione Fume d'Amor as my 2 favorite new-to-me cigars this year. Especially the Illusione, its an absolute classic IMO.