Man a $5 cutoff can get you a lot! That price point is there I hang out most of the time. Some I enjoy have been mentioned earlier. Most are maduros but a couple of others are sprinkled in. Here would be my list:

Alec Bradley Maxx
CAO America
CAO Mx2
601 Blue
Drew Estate Nica Rustica
Alec Bradley Star Insignia
L'Atelier Maduro
La Duena
Nub Maduro
Man O'War Phalanx
Rocky Patel Freedom
Tatuaje Havana VI
Tatuaje La Casita Criolla

Dang my mouth is watering now. I need a cigar bad!
La Riqueza