Worst cigar you've ever smoked

[Tman]

Tatuaje La Casita Criolla. Tasted like a pencil. I tried 2 out of a 5er. Both times chucked it less than halfway through.

I almost forgot about this one! Yeah, this is the only Tatuaje that I would not buy again.

[jhedrick83]

I almost forgot about this one! Yeah, this is the only Tatuaje that I would not buy again.

I hate to hear this. I love Conn. Broadleaf and I have a 5'er I picked up recently so I can try them, it's resting for a couple weeks more. Maybe I'll like them, who knows.

[MattyMatt]

I hate to hear this. I love Conn. Broadleaf and I have a 5'er I picked up recently so I can try them, it's resting for a couple weeks more. Maybe I'll like them, who knows.

Some people like them....you may too. Everyones palate is different. I didn't stumble upon the bad (pencil taste) reviews until after I bought them. And that is what I tasted. It is 100% broadleaf (wrapper, binder, filler)....can anyone chime in if that is the reason for the pencil taste, too much connecticut broadleaf?

[UncleFesterESQ]

Bought a bundle of Indian Tabac Super Fuerte a few years ago. WORST burn and taste of any cigar I'd ever had. Kept at them, thinking that as they aged they may come around. Never happened. An awful experience that kept on giving.

As for Vegas 5, in general, not great BUT I have enjoyed the Cask Strength Firkins.

[B daddy]

I almost forgot about this one! Yeah, this is the only Tatuaje that I would not buy again.

Damn, I just bought a fiver thinking "it's a tat. How bad could it be?"

[Tman]

Damn, I just bought a fiver thinking "it's a tat. How bad could it be?"

It's not horrible, but it left me scratching my head. I too tasted that "pencil" flavor.