6 tins

[Cool Breeze]

If I were strictly buying 6 tins I would go:

Hearth & Home 10 to Midnight - $7.49
Hearth & Home AJ's Vaper - $7.49
Orlik Golden Sliced - $6.79
SG St. James Flake - $9.29
SG Full Virginia Flake - $9.29
Dunhill Nightcap - $9.15

Total - $50.32
That's prices from P&C

Those tobaccos are all non aromatics and cover the spectrum nicely from mild to full flavored.
They are all VA, Vaper or English blends but that's pretty much all I smoke. YMMV.

However I will say since you are filling large jars, do not totally discount bulk tobacco. You can several of the ones I listed in bulk and get more baccy for the $.
Also, Peter Stokkebye is still on sale for $1.75 per ounce at P&C if you buy 4 ounces of the same stuff. Four ounces for $7 is a helluva deal.
If you get any of that I'd recommend the Luxury Bullseye Flake. It's a nice Vaper with a little unflavored Cavendish.

I'm with you on the aromatics. There are a couple I like, but they're few and far between.