-
The problem I have with the tobacco review site is that it doesn't really give me what I'm looking for. I'm looking for people's opinions of stuff to categorically stay away from.
For example, if some noob asked me the same question about cigars, I'd suggest he categorically stay away from Gurkha and 5 Vegas, among others. Obsidian, all Fonsecas, Black Pearl, CI Legends, Cu Avana, Graycliff, Xikar, Hesitant Pirate, etc. IMHO those are all crap cigars in every vitola and every line. That's a complete generalization, of course. There might be a Gurkha out there that's great. But a noob won't go wrong by staying away from any of those listed above because they have a general reputation for sh*ttiness. On a review site, some of those might even garner some decent reviews by people who like them.
What I'm looking for in this thread is for folks to state their opinions about what to completely avoid. I realize they're opinions only.
Unless its mixture 79. Just avoid that stuff and all should be good.
Just like that 
Do you have any idea of the types of tobacco you like to smoke(e.g. Virginia, Burley, English, Aromatics)?
At this point I'm trying them all.
Last edited by Ropey; 04-14-2015 at 04:07 PM.
It's not a real hobby unless it interferes with your work.
-
True Derelict
Hi Ropey,
You're asking personal advice that's like having someone pick out your shirts.

Originally Posted by
JustTroItIn
Do you have any idea of the types of tobacco you like to smoke(e.g. Virginia, Burley, English, Aromatics)?
@JustTroItIn
is right, you have to start with what kinds or types of tobacco you like.

Originally Posted by
Ropey
What I'm looking for in this thread is for folks to state their opinions about what to completely avoid. I realize they're opinions only.
Just like that
At this point I'm trying them all.
I've read glowing comments on this and other forums about a tobacco that I find I don't like. I've read reviews about tobaccos that after tasting them I have to think that they smoker was a Martian. It's personal taste.
My problem with CI Gurkhas is construction but that's largely not a problem with pipe tobacco. Start with what Jack says and I'd suggest looking into tobaccos from makers of blends that you like and avoiding ones from makers you don't like but there's no silver bullet.
Pete
-
Post Thanks / Like - 0 Thanks, 1 Likes