I've had that experience too. Several years ago I bought five tins of F&T Cut Virginia Plug. After two tins I didn't like it at all – had a "minty" flavor that put me off. But a couple of years later I opened a third tin – and loved it. Can't understand why I ever thought it tasted minty. Now it's my favorite topped Virginia – mild, tasty, and has a scrumptious tin note. Good for social situations too – everybody likes the room note.