My favorite shape is the rhodesian, But I'm not prejudice I like dublin shape. I smoked my Peterson Dublin Churchwarden with some Sweet Killarney just last night. I am not a fan of aromatics but Peterson does a good job with them. I am like Hunter Thompson "once you get locked into a serious drug-collection, the tendency is to push it as far as you can". I feel the same way about my pipe and tobacco collection. Never put a limit on things that bring you pleasure.