Sorry you had the delight issues!
I'm sure they made the experience, "less than".
And although the No. 9 is not my favorite it is still a very nice cigar. You admission to being a mild to medium smoker, I can see this not really being your "cup of tea"! Even with the rest, IMO, they don't mellow much. But then again I've never really had one with too much rest.
Hopefully if you give it anther shot it will provide a better experience.
Thanks for the review.