I had started re-smoking the McClelland 5100 Red Virginia and then was able to get a copy of my original reviews. My plan now is to post the previous review and then add any notes having smoked the same again. I'll do this with the others because I enjoyed the Peter Stokkebye Peaches & Creme and feel I may have rushed to judgement on the De Jose Gener La Escepcion. (like I need an excuse to smoke a bowl) And away we go...

From Puff:
Re: Triple Reviews from OnePyroTec's Not Your Average Type Of Trade
I'm smoking 2004 McClelland 5100 Straight Virginia. This is my forth bowl in the forth different pipe: two different MM Cobs, a Brewster, and a DR Grabow. The tobacco is a mingling of dark brown and a red tint. It smells like sweet tobacco. The taste is slightly sweet and a hint of tangyness. Nothing like the tang of a Bright Virginia. It's much more mellow. While not quick to bite, it will nip at the tongue a little if puffed a little quick. To my knowledge this is my first Red Virginia. I have enjoyed every puff and look forward to trying a Red with out this much age on it in order to compare. Certainly want to echo the thanks to @OnePyroTec for this outstanding opportunity.

Present:
I smoked three more bowls as well as smoking some I received from someone else that only has about two years on it. It is a rich tasting tobacco. Seems the ten years of aging have subdued any hint of tangyness and toned down the sweet making it deeper. I totally understand this could be a every day or all day tobacco.